Prepare a medium cooking pan. Add 1 cup of butter to the pan. Melt it over moderately low heat.
After the butter melts completely, reduce the heat. Next, add minced garlic to the pan and cook for around three minutes.
Ensure to stir the mixture constantly. If it starts to boil, try slightly turning down the heat to simmer the mixture.
Add the following ingredients: paprika, Old Bay seasoning, lemon pepper, cayenne pepper, hot sauce, lemon juice, and water.
Simmer the sauce over medium-low heat for around 15 minutes. Remember to stir it constantly so it won’t stick to the pan’s bottom or burn.
Add all remaining ingredients to the pan and stir well. Then, allow the sauce to simmer for around five minutes.
Serve it with your food right away!